Navigating Texas Zoning Changes
Legal Nonconforming Use and New Proximity Laws
Imagine you own a CBD or vape shop in Texas and your city suddenly bans such shops within 1,000 feet of a school or church. Are you about to be shut down overnight? Fortunately, Texas law provides strong protections for “legal nonconforming uses,” often called grandfathered uses, that can safeguard existing businesses like yours. In this comprehensive guide, we’ll explain what legal nonconforming use means in Texas, how state and local regulations interact, and what steps you should take to protect your property rights under new zoning changes.
What Is a Legal Nonconforming Use in Texas (Grandfathered Rights)?
When zoning laws change, a legal nonconforming use is an existing business or property use that was lawful when established but doesn’t comply with the new rules. In plain terms, it’s “grandfathered in.” Texas cities commonly write new ordinances to exempt these existing uses instead of terminating them immediately. For example, when San Antonio passed its anti-vape “BREATH” ordinance in 2025, the city noted that “existing locations within 1,000 feet [of schools/daycares] would be considered legal, nonconforming (grandfathered) as of May 8, 2025”. In other words, if your shop was open before the new rule’s effective date, you can continue operating under the old rules
Texas law explicitly protects such situations. Texas Local Government Code Chapter 211 (the municipal zoning law) says that if a zoning change makes your current use nonconforming, you “may continue to use the property in the same manner” unless and until the city formally requires you to stop. This is a crucial protection – it means a new ordinance can’t automatically nullify your existing business use. The right to carry on a previously legal use is often considered a “vested” property right.
Who Regulates Land Use? Cities vs. Counties vs. the State
Land use regulation in Texas involves municipalities, counties, and the state, but their roles differ significantly:
Cities (Municipalities) – Texas cities, especially home-rule cities, have broad zoning powers within their limits. They can decide what can be built where, control building heights, set distance buffers between certain uses, etc. For instance, a city council can enact rules about where CBD, THC, or smoke shops can operate.
Counties – By contrast, most Texas counties do not have general zoning authority. In fact, state law forbids counties like Travis County from regulating “the use of any building or property for business, industrial, or residential purposes” or imposing typical zoning rules. This means if your property is in an unincorporated area (outside city limits), there is usually no county zoning ordinance to restrict uses
The State – Texas sets the legal framework through statutes and can also impose statewide rules or limitations. For example, Texas law prohibits alcohol sales within 300 feet of a school or church in many cases. The state also can preempt or limit local zoning powers.
Can a City Shut Down My Business with a Zoning Change - or restricting a certin USe like CBD Smoke Shop?
One of the most common questions owners ask is, “Can a city just shut down my business by changing the law?” In Texas, the answer is generally no—not without giving you time or compensation. Thanks to strong property-rights protections in Texas law, a new zoning rule cannot instantly revoke your right to continue an existing lawful use. Here’s why:
Texas Constitution Protections: The Texas Constitution forbids retroactive laws that destroy vested rights. If you opened your business legally, the government cannot simply declare it illegal overnight without running afoul of this provision.
Grandfathering as the Norm: In practice, cities nearly always include grandfather clauses for existing businesses when they pass new zoning restrictions. For example, when San Antonio banned new vape and tobacco shops within 1,000 feet of schools and daycares in 2025, city officials made clear that “existing businesses within the buffer zone would be grandfathered in” Similarly, Texas alcohol regulations have long had distance limits (typically 300–1,000 feet from schools or churches), but previously existing bars or stores are usually allowed to continue operating under a grandfather clause so long as they don’t lapse in their operations. The goal is to protect established businesses while applying new rules only to new entrants or changes.
Precedents from Alcohol, Adult Business, and Game Room Regulations: In sectors like alcohol sales, sexually oriented businesses, or gaming arcades, authorities have often tried to impose new distance rules or outright bans. However, they can’t simply padlock the doors on day one of a law change. For instance, cities regulating adult entertainment venues have provided “amortization” periods – giving the business a set time (say, 5 years) to continue operating before the new ban fully applies.
Texas Local Gov’t Code 211.019 – New Protections: Recent Texas legislation has swung the pendulum even further in favor of property owners. Chapter 211 now explicitly provides that if a city requires a legal nonconforming business to stop operating, the owner must be offered remedies: either a significant payment for losses or the right to keep operating until losses are recovered. In effect, if a city tried to force you to shut down your grandfathered business, they’d have to pay you for your costs (demolition, relocation, breaking leases, etc.) and any lost property value, or let you continue running the business until you’ve made an equivalent amount of profit back.
How Cities Phase Out Nonconforming Uses: Amortization & Abandonment
Even though you can continue operating as a grandfathered use, cities may employ two key tools to eventually eliminate nonconforming uses: amortization and abandonment.
1. Amortization (Grace Periods): Amortization in zoning means giving a nonconforming business a fixed period to continue operating before the use must cease. The idea is to allow the owner time to recoup their investment (just as you amortize a loan over time) so that the impact of shutting down is lessened.
2. Abandonment (Use It or Lose It): Abandonment provisions are a common feature of zoning codes. They state that if a nonconforming use ceases for a certain period, the right to that use expires. The timeframe is often 6 months or a year, depending on the city.
Cities rely on amortization and abandonment to gradually bring neighborhoods into compliance with new plans. Instead of booting you out immediately (illegal and costly), they wait you out: either until your allowed grace period ends, or until you close up shop by choice or economic necessity. Many nonconforming uses eventually disappear due to market forces or owner decisions, allowing the new zoning rules to fully take effect over time. As an owner, it’s crucial to understand these ticking clocks. If, for instance, you know you have a 5-year sunset on your use, you can plan accordingly (perhaps seek a new location or apply for a zoning change). And if you need to pause operations, be very mindful of the abandonment time limit – consider leasing the space to a similar business temporarily rather than letting it sit vacant, or formally request an extension if available.
Registering Your Nonconforming Use – Why and How
If your business is now a legal nonconforming use (grandfathered), one smart move is to register that use with the city (if your city offers a registry or certificate process). While Texas law doesn’t require a formal registration statewide, many municipalities have a process to document your nonconforming status, and doing so can protect you in the long run.
Why Register? Registering as a nonconforming use creates an official record that your property enjoys grandfathered rights. This can streamline any future dealings with the city. For example, if you ever need a building permit, remodeling approval, or even just a change of business name on your certificate of occupancy, being on record as a legal nonconforming use prevents confusion.
What’s the Process? The process varies by city, but generally you will need to provide evidence that: (a) your use lawfully existed before the zoning change, and (b) it has continued since then without abandonment. Evidence can include permits, licenses, sales tax records, utility bills, occupancy permits, lease agreements, photographs, or affidavits – anything that shows the business was operating continuously up to the date of the ordinance and beyond.
Risks and Considerations: Failing to register isn’t necessarily fatal – you might still prove your nonconforming rights later if challenged, but it could be harder. There’s a risk that if you don’t document your status, you or a future buyer could face delays or disputes when trying to pull permits or sell the property. Also, some cities set a deadline to register after a new zoning rule; missing it might forfeit certain grandfathering benefits.
In sum, registering is about securing your “insurance policy” on your vested right. It creates clarity. As a Texas real estate owner, you want that peace of mind that your “grandfathered smoke shop” or other business is officially recognized. It can also be a selling point if you ever transfer the property – the new owner can confidently continue the business under the recorded nonconforming use (subject to the same rules of continuous operation).
Real-World Example: 4403 Commerce , San Antonio :BREATH Ordinance
To see these principles in action, let’s examine a current example in Texas: the property at 4403 Commerce Street in San Antonio. This property operates as a tobacco/vape retail shop. In May 2025, San Antonio enacted the BREATH ordinance – which stands for “Building Regulations Enhancing Anti-Vaping Trends and Habits” – as part of a public health initiative. Effective May 8, 2025, the BREATH ordinance prohibits any new tobacco store or vape shop from opening within 1,000 feet of a school, childcare center, or institution of higher learning, unless they obtain a Specific Use Authorization (“S” permit) So what does this mean for 4403 Commerce? In practical terms, a smoke, vape, THC, or CBD retailer can continue operating near schools and child care centers here – a scenario now off-limits to new businesses – giving you an exclusive foothold with no new competitors legally allowed nearby. The site is a 2,489 SF free-standing building already built out as a turn-key smoke/CBD shop, situated on a high-traffic corner near a KIPP college prep school and Our Lady of the Lake University. High visibility, ample parking, and a built-in customer base from surrounding institutions make it an ideal zoning-compliant location for cannabis accessories and CBD retail. Whether you’re an investor eyeing a high-demand asset or a retailer seeking prime retail space for lease, 4403 W. Commerce delivers a unique “regulatory moat” protecting your business from competition. Opportunities like this – essentially the only smoke shop for sale near a school in Texas that’s fully compliant – are virtually nonexistent under current regulations. Don’t miss the chance to secure this grandfathered vape shop in San Antonio.
Stay Informed and Protect Your Property Rights
Don’t let land use changes blindside your business + Real Estate Assets
Across Texas, land use laws are shifting fast—city by city, ordinance by ordinance. From San Antonio’s BREATH rule to local crackdowns on smoke shops and new legislation targeting THC or CBD retail near schools, the regulatory ground under commercial real estate is anything but stable. If you own or invest in property, you can’t afford to be caught flat-footed.
Understanding concepts like legal nonconforming use, grandfathered rights, and forced amortization isn’t just legal trivia—it’s how you keep your property operating, valuable, and protected. These aren’t theoretical risks. They’re real threats to your leaseability, cash flow, and resale value.
That’s where we come in. We translate policy into plain English and break down exactly how new laws impact your business strategy, so you’re never scrambling to respond after the fact.
Want expert insight before the headlines hit?
📬 Subscribe to our newsletter—tailored for Texas property owners, investors, and commercial brokers.
📱 Follow us on social media for real-time alerts, analysis, and behind-the-scenes commentary on zoning battles that matter.
We watch the fine print so you can focus on execution. Don’t just react—position yourself to win, even as the rules change.